Research into Brexit effectsInternational Trade & Investment Related pages
Brexit is inherently uncertain, but that does not mean that there cannot be any form of research into various options and the expected consequences for the Netherlands and the Dutch economy. Here we will discuss the most important general and sector-specific reports and useful tools/databases to prepare as well as you can and to stay up to date with the latest developments.
Statistics Netherlands (Centraal Bureau voor de Statistiek) and the Rabobank investigated the consequences of a Brexit based on a WTO scenario. Statistics Netherlands concluded that Brexit will cost the Dutch economy up to 1,2% of GDP (EUR 10 billion) in economic growth in 2030, due to the high degree of dependency on the British economy relative to other European economies.
Rabobank estimates an even larger fall in economic growth due to Brexit: up to 4,25% lower growth in 2030. The high estimate is caused by a different methodology: it considers imported inflation and a setback in British labour productivity in its analysis. Statistics Netherlands also offers a Brexit Monitor, in case you are interested in macroeconomic data related to Brexit.
The report written by KPMG, commissioned by the Ministry of Economic Affairs, focuses on the non-tariff costs of the hardest possible Brexit, where WTO rules would apply to trade between the UK and the EU. It considers 6 sectors in particular to elucidate the dynamics associated with trading with the UK based on WTO rules. Although the findings cannot be extrapolated to the entire economy, the report does serve as a useful starting point for Dutch companies that are trying to assess the impact of a hard Brexit on their cost structure. The report only considers non-tariff barriers (ntb’s), it does not take into account tariff barriers.
- Customs declarations will increase by 752,000 for imports and by 4,2 million for exports (based on 2016 data).
- 77,000 turnover tax numbers (omzetbelasting-nummers, ob-numbers) will face a communitarian acquisition and/or delivery to the UK, of which 35,000 ob-numbers have no experience with trading with a third country.
- The ntb’s can be divided into two categories: general and sector-specific.
- KPMG has estimated that the general levy will be at least EUR 78,20 to EUR 126,70 per shipment. Besides that, it is likely that the ferry traffic will face delays due to customs formalities, due to limited capacity with the customs authorities.
- The increase in declarations is likely to cause shortages in capacity with service providers as well, e.g. customs officers and experts.
The 6 sectors assessed were: meat, cut flowers, paint, means of communication (mobile phones and routers/modems), fire extinguishers and accountancy. These 6 sectors were chosen since they provide for a useful overview of the different dynamics within sectors associated with post-Brexit trade based on WTO rules. The report emphasises that the results cannot be translated to other sectors one-on-one, however, it does provide for a helpful starting point.
The Dutch embassy in the UK offers a broad overview of sectors in which the Netherlands has a strong presence. Here you can find reports on the British market and relevant liaisons in your sector.
The agrofood sector (or: foods and drinks sector) is a clear example of a sector that will be affected by Brexit along multiple channels. Out of total Dutch exports of EUR 469 billion in 2017, EUR 91.7 billion consisted of exports in agricultural products (19.6%): agrofood is very important to Dutch exports. The UK is the third largest export partner within this sector: in 2017 EUR 8.7 billion in agricultural products was exported to the UK. Brexit does seem to cast its shadow ahead due to the devaluation of the sterling: the 1% growth in exports to the UK is significantly slower than the 7% increase in total exports of agricultural products. Relatively low margins in combination with import tariffs could significantly affect competitiveness of Dutch exports on the UK market. Long queues at customs by the separation of the UK from the internal market could pose problems to perishable goods. Furthermore, diverging quality demands could lead to extra checks, implying extra costs and
delays in your supply chain. Branch organisations could help you with Brexit. For the agrofood sector these are:
The maritime sector is one of the heaviest-affected by Brexit. The KiM (Kennisinstituut voor Mobiliteitsbeleid), a research unit of the Ministry of Infrastructure and Water Management, wrote a Ministry of Infrastructure and Water Management wrote a report on the consequences of Brexit for maritime transport from and to Dutch sea ports (unfortunately the report is only available in Dutch). The report looks at the effects of Brexit in 2030. It considers two scenarios: hard and soft Brexit. Hard Brexit is where the UK and the EU would trade according to WTO rules 2019 onwards (and there would be no trade agreement concluded between the UK and the EU). Soft Brexit is where the UK and the EU would trade according to WTO rules in the period 2019-2029, but according to a trade agreement 2030 onwards. The trade agreement is assumed to be a mix between the ones the EU has with Switzerland, Turkey and Canada.
- A hard Brexit will lead to a decline of the outbound market of 4.4% compared to a no-Brexit-scenario, and a decline of 2.6% in case of a soft Brexit.
- The inbound market will shrink by 2.0 to 3.7%, depending on the scenario.
- The differences between the largest sea ports of the Netherlands for the inbound transport are quite similar. For the port of Rotterdam this effect comes down to 1.9 to 3.5%. Given the scale relative to the other ports, Rotterdam will face the largest decline in absolute numbers compared to no Brexit: 3.3 to 5.8 million tonnes less in 2030 (based on 2015 data).
- There are large differences between the ports when it comes to outbound transport. Vlissingen/Terneuzen (4.0 to 8.0% less), Rotterdam (2.5 to 4.5% less) and Amsterdam (0.5 to 1.0% less) will all feel the consequences of Brexit, but to a different extent. As with inbound, Rotterdam will face the largest decline due to Brexit: 5.7 to 10.6 million tonnes will flow into the harbour of Rotterdam due to Brexit.
- Dutch shipowners will not experience a large decline in their competitivity. Mostly Dutch ports will be less competitive if the UK decides to alter its legislation regarding ports. Most prominently: state aid, customs activities, environment and security, cabotage rules for sea transport, fewer permits for non-British drivers and the establishment of ‘Free Trade Zones’.